About This Blog

The purpose of my blog is mostly for review, film analysis, and other posts relating to popular culture. I always love to entertain and love to share the wonderful things I see. Join me on a journey through my life and the world

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Wallflower Blush and Forgotten Friendship: An Analysis

There’s probably nothing less timely than making a blogpost about My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic in 2026.  There’s probably also nothing super exciting about being a guy in his 30’s doing that.  Still, this blog mostly exists for me to work out and have a place for my thoughts, so if I have a strong desire to do something, I will.  Thus, I’ll be doing an analysis of a character that interests me: Wallflower Blush.

Wallflower is a character in the spinoff series, My Little Pony: Equestria Girls, mythos.  Specifically, it’s the series set in an alternate universe with the characters’ human versions.  Wallflower was the villain from the first hour-long special, “Forgotten Friendship,” in the series and the first not to turn into or be a giant monster.  There was an interesting level of humanity to her character that can be easily seen.

In addition, she played a part in helping define series favorite and lead, Sunset Shimmer.  The episode helped set the tone for the series as well as set up what it could or would be going forward.  As a result, it will be fun to analyze her character, philosophy as an antagonist, and why some may find her relatable.

Now, because this will be discussing a character, there will obviously be spoilers.  If not interested, here’s your point to stop.  Otherwise, feel free to continue.

For a brief overview of “Forgotten Friendship,” Sunset Shimmer and her friends are members of the yearbook committee and are putting the finishing touches on what’s about to be submitted.  Unfortunately, overnight, all her friends mysteriously forget everything that had happened to them over the last few months.  Prior to that, she had a notorious reputation as the school bully, something she’s tried to (and succeeded at) make up for since.

Unable to find support amongst her friends, she returns to her home dimension (where the main series takes place) to team up with her only other friend, unicorn Twilight Sparkle, to find out what happened.  Eventually, they figure out that a missing stone from long ago had the power to erase memories and that Sunset Shimmer has until Sundown to destroy it so that she can restore her friends’ memories.  Along the way, she teams up with another series antagonist, Trixie, who empathizes with Sunset’s situation, and they go on a quest to find who at their high school has the stone.

Eventually, they find out that the person who holds the stone is Wallflower Blush, the other member of the yearbook committee that everyone forgot about.  In fact, the fact that people are forgetting her is why she decided to take out that frustration on Sunset and try to prove that the former bully is just as bad as she’d always been.  After a series of back-and-forths between them, Sunset is able to destroy the stone, make amends with Wallflower, and everything goes back to normal.

Despite barely being in the episode, Wallflower does play a key role by putting Sunset in the scenario that sets up the episode in the first place.  The episode asks the question “What would happen if you were only remembered for the worst moments of your life?”  As a former bully, taking away the more positive and recent memories results in Sunset only being seen as a monster, despite the fact that that’s no longer a fair representation of her character.

Wallflower’s motivations for doing so are, simply put, envy.  Despite having absolutely no history with Sunset, she finds it unfair that the former mean girl has her image improved after a lot of the horrible things she did.  In fact, it’s because she has no relationship to Sunset that Wallflower gets envious of Sunset.  After all, she never did anything wrong, at least directly, and yet she has no friends while Sunset, having been horrible previously, now has at least six and more as the days continue.

Going back to Wallflower’s lack of friends, it’s primarily because almost no one knows that she exists.  It’s commented that she’s known Sunset since freshman year, but Sunset doesn’t remember her name.  It’s worse when Trixie admits the same and she’s known Wallflower since third grade.  It’s made clear throughout the episode that Wallflower knows absolutely no one despite having made some level of connections since being young.  In the end, she had no one, and thus no one to stop her worst impulses.

What makes the episode compelling is the divide between Sunset and Wallflower.  Both came from different backgrounds with Wallflower being more apathetic towards the world while Sunset was outright villainous when she was first introduced.  Yet, the toxic one became a friend to all, head of the yearbook committee, stage director for the play later, and had many, many, many adventures alongside the people closest to her while Wallflower Blush faded out of existence.  It doesn’t seem fair purely from an outside perspective.

It’s because the modern Sunset, the post movie 1 Sunset, is an actually virtuous person.  Sure, she still has anger issues that are extremely entertaining to watch, but she does actually care very much about people and she does want to be a part of the community around her.  Her willingness to try and make friends/reason with Wallflower before destroying the stone as well as work with a traditional enemy in Trixie is evidence enough of that desire.  So even when removed from the new reality, she really is a better person now.

Wallflower, on the other, hasn’t done anything.  Not merely anything wrong, just hasn’t done anything.  In a way, she’s given up on life and isn’t making the effort.  It’s not unfair since people aren’t making an effort with her, but she’s become resigned to accept that and has given up on that ever changing in a positive way.  In contrast to Sunset who refuses to give up until every option has been considered, Wallflower accepts victimhood and doesn’t make the effort to improve.


The memory stone also makes a bit of a double edged sword in her life as well.  She’s taken to using it to eliminate memories others have of her embarrassing moments, thus making people forget her and killing her chance at developing intimate relationships.  In the end, her biggest enemy wasn’t Sunset Shimmer but herself.

Now, certain members of the adult MLP fandom tend to hold her completely responsible for people not knowing who she is and no one remembers her.  After all, if she has a stone that can remove memories and does use it when interactions don’t go her way, then surely it is her fault that no one remembers her.

Well, Wallflower acknowledges this when she finally realizes she crossed a line and had a moment of clarity before apologizing.  However, it’s not completely fair to say that it’s 100% her fault that no one remembers her since she only got the stone in high school and Trixie admitted to not knowing who she is before that.  Keep in mind, we also get flashback scenes of Wallflower being ignored before getting the stone and there’s no evidence that she eliminated every memory before that point.  So she was struggling with a usually friendly world before that which explains why she felt disconnected from the broader community.

Which goes back to the theme of the story.  The main message of the story is that we shouldn’t merely avoid being a bad person to others but that we should actively make an effort to be good to others.  Friendship is a two-way street (three-way if we include Aristotle’s thoughts on relationships) so a relationship can only exist if we make an effort.  As a result, we have to try with others just as they need to try with us.

Wallflower was unable to have a relationship both because others ignored her and she gave up on trying.  It led her to a place where she lost the ability to connect with others and as a result developed an unpleasant approach to life.  Yet, when people tried to make an effort with her, she became more social and willing to be a part of groups.  So, she wasn’t irredeemable and it was always possible to make that connection with the right push.

Unfortunately, her character development kind of fell off after that.  She only appeared in the background in future segments while other villains or one-off characters actually got more screen time to hang out with the main cast.  It became ironic that one of the messages of the episode was not to let the worst moment in one’s life become their only defining moment, but that ended up happening to Wallflower.

As mentioned earlier, there’s a section of the fandom that hates Wallflower.  Part of it’s because of her victim complex, part of it’s because of how far she went with the use of her stone, and part of it’s because of her going after Sunset who really didn’t deserve it (at that time in her life).  As a result, though she still has some fans, for others she didn’t age well.

I, however, disagree with the hate for a couple reasons.  First, the show always had a natural tendency to forgive or redeem its villains.  Sometimes, that may have been given too quickly, but Wallflower was hardly a special case.  So blaming her when it’s a consistent trope seems unfair.

Also, keeping in mind that the demographic is for younger children (especially girls), it’s not surprising that there is such a focus on downplaying some of the darker elements of Wallflower’s character.  The average child isn’t going to steal memories but they may do things to ruin another’s reputation out of spite.  As a kid who’s still learning morality, showing forgiveness and a way to achieve it can remind them that we can still make up for our mistakes.

Which goes to the final/biggest defense of Wallflower: she’s a teenager.  That’s hardly an excuse, but it’s important to remember that she is still learning.  The show actually reminds of that right before she apologizes.

In the final fight, she realizes that her plan failed, miserably, and that everyone loves Sunset because she actually is a good person now.  In a last ditch effort to win, she tries to erase Sunset’s friends’ memories of the last three years to wipe out any chance at connection.  Instead, Sunset sacrifices her own memories in a bid to at least save her friends’ relationships with each other even if not herself.  Fortunately, the memories and relationships are all restored once the stone is destroyed, but it was still a horrible thing to do.

Yet, you can see on Wallflower’s face and in her demeanor that she knows she went WAY too far.  Her face softens and then she looks guiltily at what she did after the fact.  So this really was more of an emotional outburst than a statement on her character.

The human brain can keep developing into your 30s so it’s not surprising that she made an impulsive decision to double down when things weren’t going her way.  Also, she lacked a support network that could tell her she needed to stop in a healthy or just any real help developing social empathy.  Really, it goes back to not thinking it through and difficulty with relationships.  She’s still responsible for her actions, but even she knew that and took that responsibility when she apologized.  It’s why, despite being an antagonist, I wouldn’t call her rotten.  Like any flower, given the right sunlight, water, and care, she could still be redeemed and I believe was.

Which is probably why Sunset was so quick to forgive her.  After all, Sunset was just as bad in her first film and it took an entire second film for the school to trust her again.  Likely, she didn’t want Wallflower to go through what she did and wanted her to have a path back to forgiveness.  For that reason, Sunset really did learn something from this experience and it’s a reminder what a good person she is throughout the series.

All-in-all, the episode’s a great reminder about the importance of forgiveness, social connection, and shows the importance of making an effort as opposed to merely avoiding doing bad.  Wallflower is probably the second best villain in the series (after the Dazzlings) because she’s both relatable and serves as a good example on how to treat people in her situation.  It also has a lot of great Sunset Shimmer moments and further redeemed Trixie in the eyes of the fans.  Overall, it’s a great episode and probably the best special of the fourth.  If interested, it’s free on YouTube so give it a watch.